My Article: Big Questions About Wine Auctions

A wine merchant friend of mine from Hong Kong sent me a startling photo of all the auction catalogues he had on his desk just for this month. I counted 14 in all and I am sure he might have missed a few. And it’s only September. Many more sales are coming in October, November, and December.

I have to ask a few questions. Do enough wine buyers in the world – primarily Asia – exist to absorb all this? What about the volatile economy? Are people still happy to spend loads of money on expensive bottles?

I know that many people are selling wines from their cellars at the moment – especially the United States.

Global wine auctions sales in 2010 hit an estimated $408.1 million in 2010, according to a story in The Wine Spectator. Hong Kong alone accounted for $165 million of that – outpacing the United States by about $11 million. Figures so far this year look similar to 2010 despite the downturn in the economy.

Fourth quarter, however, is going to tell the story. And it’s all about Asia.

As one friend recently noted, “The only markets that are strong are the Chinese markets and wine investment funds. Other wine collectors around the world are not willing to pay such high prices as those in Hong Kong auctions. So many top wine cellars are going to Hong Kong sales.”

SHARE ON:
FacebookTwitterLinkedInEmail

Leave comment

You must be logged in to post comment. LOG IN

5 thoughts on “My Article: Big Questions About Wine Auctions

  1. tp096255 says:
    Well, I've got some cult wines out there for auction so lets hope for good Asian action!
  2. dnoone says:
    I noted this in the Board comments awhile back - there is a HUGE amount of fine wine in the auction market on top of the 2010 BDX en primeur campaign, on top of 2009s hitting the shelves, on top of a touted 2009 Burgundy vintage on top of 2009 Rhones, on top of 2006 Brunellos, on top of a potentially stunning 09 Cali Pinots ...and on an on. Aggregate it all up and you have the makings potentially of a pretty hard crash in fine wine prices. I have decided to forgo fine wine purchases for 18 months to see what happens, there will be more than enough wine around to buy at that point and it could all be much cheaper.
  3. James Suckling says:
    Thank you for the comment. I think that a lot of people are waiting to buy wines at the moment.
  4. mscott says:
    There are a lot of people waiting on the collectables in the US, for sure. I've even been buying less trophy wines and focusing on the "drinkables", for the time being. When you have such magnificent vintages like what we have seen for the past five years from the major wine regions and escalating prices - implosion is only a matter of time.

    I'm pretty much in the same proverbial boat as DNOONE, only buying a bottle here and there.
  5. chrwu says:
    Even wine funds have been treading with caution and our wine merchants here are having a lot of sales on (singapore), despite wine being a wholly different asset class, it does remain correlated to the stock market and the economic cycle. Without the Chinese the last few months would have probably been worse.